CENTRE for POLICY ANALYSIS

CENTRE for POLICY ANALYSIS

“Social progress can be measured by the social position of the female sex” - Karl Marx

OPINION


Why Arguments Against Reservation are Flawed


Reservations are one of the most debated topics in India but in many of these discussions the question of social justice is completely sidelined. Social justice needs to be understood in terms of representation and integration of the members of Scheduled Castes and Tribes and backward classes in the social mainstream. One out of four Indians continues to practice untouchability a study conducted by the NCAER and the University of Maryland in 2014 found. Almost every third Hindu (30%) admitted to the practice, followed by Sikhs (23%), Muslims (18%) and Christians (5%). Thus, questioning the reservation system instead of the flaws in social justice delivery is the biggest irony of the reservation debate.  

The general perception about reservations is that they are "perpetuating caste". It is even more ironic that this argument has any currency today, considering OBC candidates are being denied reservations at the all-India level under the National Eligibility Cum Entrance Test (NEET). This is understood to have denied 11,000 candidates from backward classes an opportunity to compete for seats in medical and dental colleges around the country since 2017. This denial of representation coincides with their almost negligible presence in central and state universities and other institutions.  

The concept of creamy layer among OBC has further diluted their institutional representation. In a way, rather than creating a class distinction, the creamy layer concept has contributed to diluting the purpose of reservations, which is to ensure integration of the oppressed masses and the privileged few. A similar logic of creamy layer also may expand to SC/STs.

Most anti-reservation arguments lack newness, for they are largely based on a sense of deprivation among the relatively privileged. Their opposition to reservations also widens the social gap in India along primordial identities. Many arguments against reservation are also a Brahmanical gimmick, wherein Dalit-Bahujans are painted in inferior light. Social media is adding to this cacophony by circulating rumours about how affirmative action in the form of reservation compromises merit, promotes caste, and so on.  

The fundamental premise of these arguments is flawed for the elite castes have not yet distanced themselves from their social, political, cultural and economic privileges. To understand these privileges consider the representation of the privileged members of the upper castes in the bureaucracy, media, judiciary, educational institutions, and so on. The OBCs were only 8.05% of Group "A" and "B" employees in the Indian Railways, only 15% of the Cabinet Secretariat, and 8.42% of the Human Resource Development Ministry, the Indian Express recently reported. (The backward classes are entitled to 27% reservations in central government employment.)  

Contestations to the reservation system go back to former prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru's time. On 27 June 1961, in letters to chief ministers, Nehru wrote, "It is true that we are tied up with certain rules and conventions about helping Scheduled Castes and Tribes. They deserve help but, even so, I dislike any kind of reservation, more particularly in service."

While paradoxical ideas are being spread about reservations, one needs to look closely at the historical underpinnings of why the policy came to exist. It was introduced by Shahuji Maharaj, the ruler of Kolhapur, in 1902 as 50% reservations for backwards and Dalits. Reservation was explicitly discussed during the Poona Pact of 1932, when Babasaheb Ambedkar pitched for separate electorates along with Rettamalai Srinivasan.

However, the inclusion of the Dalits in education and jobs impinges on the continuation of reservations-refer to the NCAER report cited above and numerous other studies that illustrate their active and ongoing discrimination. Yet, contradictory winds seem to keep blowing, wherein reservations in education and jobs are being nullified in practice by heavily privatising educational institutions and contractualising employment. This has compromised university access and job opportunities for all underprivileged students, the least privileged SC/ST students in particularly.  

Reservation mandates 49.5% seats to be reserved for SCs, STs and OBCs, while the rest fall in the general category which is also known as unreserved or UR. Now because the government has introduced 10% reservations for Economically Weaker Sections or EWS candidates, the general category stands at 40%. But what really exposes the casteist mindset is that non-general students who qualify on the so-called merit list are often spurned by institutions and their peers and asked to seek admission in the "reserved" category instead. This exposes how the charge of lacking "merit" is a ruse to halt democratisation of institutions. Fact is, non-reserved seats are seen by "upper" caste candidates as belonging to them.

Since the late eighties, Dalit-Bahujan job aspirants have complained that they are categorised by examiners and interviewers as "Not found Suitable" or NFS. They say that this is done as a strategy to raise the bar of entry so that SC, ST and OBCs are unable to cross the threshold of government service.

Another argument that is often pitched against the reservation system is that it has benefited "very few" or that it is a "failed" policy. However, the benefits of reservation reaches a small number of SC, ST and OBC aspirants only because fewer and fewer vacancies are being created in the government sector. This is not a problem of the reservation policy per se. Reservation is aimed to ensure adequate "representation" to those who have been historically denied access to institutional spaces or are socially and educationally backward by virtue of their class/caste location.

Ensuring wider representation to oppressed and left-behind communities can ensure their social and psychological integration on every field on the national stage. It is a mockery that a country with 85% Dalit-Bahujan composition has them as the least-represented section. The question is, how poorly are reservations being implemented that their benefits fail to reach the intended beneficiaries?

What people who oppose reservation choose to forget is that it is just an entry criterion, and when it comes to performance its beneficiaries do not get any benefits or relaxations. Besides, time and again, the students from social categories eligible for reservations have proven their excellence. In 2018, a Stanford University finding that ST and SC engineering students, followed by OBC students, "learn at a faster rate than those from the general category" was widely reported. The report also found that the "gains in learning are higher in elite institutions-IITs and NITs- compared to non-elite institutions". This points towards the urgent need to improve the quality of our public institutions and build more of them rather than bicker over who gets to study in them.

The Stanford study proves that when given an equitable opportunity SC, ST and OBC students have the same potential and can outperform their peers in any field. In the garb of anti-reservation arguments, the main objective is to target students along caste lines and make them feel inferior.

That the reservation system does not re-create the caste system is proven by statistics which reveal the sharp rise in violence against members of the SC, ST and non-elite sections of the OBC communities. Anti-reservation propagandists need to check their facts. What creates caste is the violent social structure of stratification and not the affirmative action which gives hope to Dalit-Bahujan to transcend the boundaries of caste.

Are members of elite castes ready to sacrifice their privileges? If not, they have their answer to why reservation is needed, for the old social hierarchy of caste still prevails. Reservation is just one step to deconstruct the psychological notions that support this social order.  

For the oppressed, inclusive politics is not divorced from political resistance. In other words, making political claims are a way for the suppressed to contest their status in caste society. A politics overwhelmed by elite castes is not critiqued for being "casteist". The Constitution ensures social, political and economic democracy and reservations are enshrined in it as a great leveller of the uneven terrain. Unfortunately, its flawed implementation is ignored and anti-reservation sentiments get centre-stage thanks to misplaced arguments.

Kalyani is a doctoral candidate at the Center for the Study of Social Systems, Jawaharlal Nehru University, and Prashant Ingole is a doctoral candidate in Humanities and Social Sciences at the Indian Institute of Technology, Gandhinagar. The views are personal.  

     

OPINION

  • River in a 'Court of Law' - Legal issues pertaining to its personality
  • Syria: A Testament To International Moral Bankruptcy
  • When the State Sought to Muzzle Privacy, U-Turn Now Only to Accommodate SC Verdict
  • The Bull in A China Shop Wrecks Indian Economy
  • When Buddha Looks The Other Way: The Plight Of The Rohingya
  • A Fatal Blow to The Judiciary
  • The Dramatic Rise in Wealth Inequality
  • Wild And Baseless Speculations of Crisis in the CPI(M)
  • Budget 2018: Fantabulous Schemes With Not A Paisa Earmarked
  • Kasganj: Sankalp Foundation and the Politics of Hate
  • PM Modi Sounds the Election Bugle: Congress and Hindutva the Agenda for 2019 Polls
  • The US Game Plan in Syria
  • Both Nehru and Patel Were the Need of the Hour in 1947-48
  • The Battle of the Two Begums of Bangladesh
  • Why Bangladesh Matters
  • Kejriwal's Apology is Not What the Media Claims
  • Arrest of a '5-minute Dalits' Proves Why SC/ST Act Dilution Will Grossly Impact Real Dalits
  • The Dalits and the Law
  • Winners May Be Losers In Karnataka's Catch 22 Endgame
  • Jinnah and the BJP
  • Jawaharlal Nehru (Nov 14 1889- May 27, 1964): We Still Live In A House That Nehru Built
  • Implications of Trump-Kim Summit: Nuclear Pays!
  • Thomas Reuters Foundation Survey: Measuring Safety, Generating Outrage
  • ROADMAP TO A CEASEFIRE: AFGN - PAK
  • What Are People Voting for?
  • Foreign Policy: A Double Whammy Awaits India
  • Changing Discourse
  • Assam: The Mythology of "Immigrants"
  • Imran Time is Here
  • 71 Years on, Forsty Relations Countinue
  • To Stop Climate Change, We Need to Open Bordera
  • Make Use of Bid to Postpone Provincial Elections
  • Cringing and Fuddled at 71
  • Ensuring Strident Voice Will Not Become Majority Voice
  • Nehru, Vajpayee and Modi
  • Religious Bias Okayed
  • The Oslo Accords: A Bloody Legacy of Betrayal
  • Crushing the Campus
  • Three Stories And Task of The Office Of Missing Person
  • Drama Over Indo-Pak Meeting
  • An ill Wind
  • Symbolic Actions Alone Are Insufficient For Long Term Change To Occur
  • If Democracy Subverts Itself
  • Returning Land to Civilians is a Promise That Needs Follow Up
  • Democracy In Crisis: What we Know and What we Don't
  • Reparations Office Can Bind The Nations Together
  • Implementation Challenges Facing The Ayushman Bharat Program
  • Subverting the Central Bank
  • Under the Yoke of New-Imperialism: A Fake War of Patriotism and Treason
  • India Joins the Club
  • The Third Phase
  • President is Best Situated to Resolve Political Crisis
  • No Country for Adventure: Challenges Extreme Sports Athletes Face in India
  • Setting A Perilous Political Precedent
  • What Rahul and Modi can do in the Next Four Months
  • Finding a Win-Win Solution to Break the Deadlock
  • Temple in the Age of Colliders
  • Four Parameters of a Political Solution at This Time
  • Resolve National Question With President's Support
  • Decapitating the Leadership
  • Four Takeaways From the 2018 Election
  • Science of Words
  • The Ace up Modi's Sleeve
  • The Government Must Not Deny The TNA
  • The Prolonged Wait For Justice And For Political Leadership
  • Endgame in Afghanistan
  • Pluralist Ethos is More Relevant to National Identity
  • A Concerned Citizen's Points For Inclusion in The Manifesto of Political Parties
  • In My Own Voice: Circle of Unreason
  • RBI To The Rescue of Modi Government - It's Election Time!
  • Say No to War
  • A terrifying Fallout
  • The Type of Leadership The Country Needs
  • Death Wish as Nationalism
  • Politics on Kashmir Need Not be About Optics Alone
  • Why an Urban Job Guarantee Scheme is Not a Bad Idea
  • National Security: The New in 'New Normal'
  • Re-Promulgating an Ordinance is a Fraud on the Constitution
  • Elections 2019: India at a Crossroads
  • Peace and Inclusive Development
  • NYAY Providing Basic Income Fulfills the Vision of Mahatma Gandhi and Changed Election Narrative Based on Basic Issues
  • Advani Should Blame Himself For Promoting Modi
  • Kashmir: Tracing the Degeneration of Mainstream Politics
  • Elections and the Issue of Civil Liberties
  • Jumlanomics:Chronicles of a Post-Truth Bharat
  • BJP: Hiding Failures, Targeting Nehru
  • A Mayawati Moment
  • Godse is a Synonym of Hindu Nationalism, Agenda of the RSS Combine!
  • Development Beyond Numbers
  • A Rational Approach to Countering Extremist Violence is Needed
  • In My Own Voice: Is This the Sprit of Democracy?
  • Prevention is The Best Migration Cure
  • The Rise of Hate
  • The Right Mantras for India's Change
  • Coming Home - Where Family Overpowers All
  • Easter Sunday Bombing Used to Create a Major Rift in Sri Lankan Society
  • Hacking Humanity
  • Environmental Rule of Law in India
  • Peace is a Word That West Has Taken From Afghans
  • Trump's War Games
  • Modi & States
  • Who is an 'Outsider' in West Bengal?
  • China on Maps
  • 19th Amendment Will Correct Itself at End of President's Current Term
  • Authoritarianism and the Crisis of Public Ethics in India
  • Presidential Candidate The People Want
  • Has India's Kashmir Cape Given Pakistan Reason for War?
  • Icons and Ideology of Religious Nationalism
  • Why NRC in Assam May Create Another Kashmir
  • Campaign to Abolish the Executive Presidency in Sri Lanka is a Red Herring
  • As US Tries to Isolate Iran, China Steps In
  • Of Hindi and Hierarchy
  • Why Sri Lankan Elections May Bring Far Reaching Change
  • What US Policy Tells Us About India's Growing 'Friendship' With It
  • Gandhian Philosophy is a Critique of Modernity and Power
  • Inner Party Democracy is Just as Important as Funding
  • India's Foreign Policy Has Dug Itself a Deep Hole
  • 'Broken Promises' and Politics of Hate': Is Political Autonomy The Way Forward For J&K?
  • The Ninth Betrayal: America Has Let Down Khurd, Yet Again
  • Who Benefits From The WhatsApp Hacking Case?: Pertinent Question Left Unanswered
  • State Elections Results Expose "Limits" of BJP's Nationalist Agenda
  • "Religious Belief" vs. "Rule of Law": Did SC's Ayodhya Verdict Legalise Building of a Theocratic State?
  • What Does Trump's "New Refugee Ban" Mean for America's Immigrants?
  • India Must Change Course as Rajapaksas Return on Sinhala Buddhist Wave
  • The Supreme Court's First Judgment Without an Author
  • Geopolitics in South Asia Renders Millions Stateless
  • "Shakespeare's Vision of the Improbale" Unfolds: Is Modi Today's Macbeth?
  • Sri Lanka Under Rajapaksa: Finding Areas of Mutual Agreement
  • "The Game of Religion is Played by Men": Women Speak From the Margins of Ayodhya Dispute
  • Telangana Ecounter- Failure of Local Police Poses Grave Danger to Democracy
  • The Changing Nature of War and Diplomacy
  • Sri Lanka: Government's Cooperation A "Temporary Phenomenon"?
  • The Role of Corruption in This Season of Revolts
  • New Citizenship Law to a "Brazenly Divisive Agenda"
  • Youth Agitation Against CAA Brings a Historic Generational Shift
  • "Digital Authoritarianism": With Internet Shutdowns Normalised, the Digital Space is Democracy's New Battleground
  • Sri Lanka: The Challenge of Development Amidst Devolution of Power
  • The Political Divides that Split India
  • 'Never Again': Echoes of Nazi Crimes Remain Alive 75 Years After Auschwitz
  • "Legacy of Mutual Suspicion" Plagues Opponents of the Modi Regime
  • "Toxic" India Sliding into an Environmental Abyss
  • Manufacturing Hate: From Anurag Thakur's 'Shoot the Traitors' to Pistol-Bearing Youth's 'Yeh lo Azaadi!'
  • Kejriwal Isn't Communal, But His Desire Not to be Seen Anti-Hindu May Prove Self-Defeating
  • Religion States Won't Oppose US-Taliban Deal
  • Lessons From Pathogens: Coronavirus, A wake Up Call?
  • The Geopolitics of the Covid 19 Pandemic
  • Cold War Begins As Nations Fued Over Coronavirus
  • India Fights Coronavirus...With Scriptures, Morals and Police
  • The Burden of COVID 19
  • Do Israeli Settelemnts in Occupies West Bank Constitute a War Crime ?
  • The Global Debate on COVID-19 Lockdown: Listen to Divergent Scientific Voices or Risk Manipulation by Big Businesses?
  • Sri Lanka's Easter Bombings And The Demand For Justice
  • How India Can Solve the "Catch-22 Situation" of Allowing Migrant Workers to Return Home
  • The Time for Universal Basic Income Has Arrived
  • COVID-19 Crisis Exposes Fatal Weaknesses of 'Strong' Leaders
  • The Pandemic Has Taught Us the Importance of Maintaining an Ecological Balance, Will we Remember IT?
  • The Muslim Elite Has Let Down the Muslim Poor
  • "There is Nothing Nationalist or Non-Nationalist in Reporting"
  • Why WHO Took 3 Months to Declare a Global Pandemic
  • A Political Lockdown That Silences Voices
  • The 'Relief Package' of Online Education May End up "Institutionalising Drop Outs"
  • Can Democracy Survive the Coronavirus?
  • As China Ups the Ante, This is What India Must do...
  • Tackling Racism With Compassionate Reporting-CNN Leads The Way
  • Sri Lanka: Pluralism In Governance Required In The Absence of Parliament
  • Idia's Tactical Non-Solutions To China's Incursions in Ladakh
  • "At The Brink of A New Cold War": Sino-US Ties at a Crossroads
  • In Light of Rising Conservatism, Can The Personal be Political Again?
  • India-China: The Complete Breakdown of Trust, How and Why
  • Rethinking Development After Covid-19
  • The Pandemic Must Transform Our Agriculture
  • Treacherous Road to Make Manu History
  • The 'American Way of War' Is Built On A Foundation of Racism
  • Covid -19 And The Crisis of Education-An Insight
  • Governments That Preach Non-Violence Must Lead By Example
  • New Status of Hagia Sophia Signals The Death Of Secularism
  • Covid 19 and Furthering of Sectarian Agenda in Education
  • Biden's "Conventional" Approach vs Trump's "Whimsical" Handling of Foreign Policy
  • Why Arguments Against Reservation are Flawed
  • Curfew Welcomes One Year of Abrogations in Kashmir
  • Ayodha: What is BJP's Motive For Holding Ram Temple Ceremony Amid Pandemic?
  • New Education Policies of India And Pakistan Will Further Divide, Within and Without
  • Does India's Handling of China Make Sense?
  • Return of the Rajapaksas in Sri Lanka
  • An Independent Supreme Court Is a Must for Democracy
  • Does Rule of Law Trump Tide of Public Opinion?
  • UAE-Israel Deal Accelerating Fragmentation of West Asian Politics
  • Congress And Its "Unprecedented Political Challenge""
  • Does The 20th Amendment Threaten Pluralism in Sri Lanka?
  • Digital Hate, Now A Profitable Commodity
  • Rising Cases, Unemployment: Is India Ignoring Fears Stoked by the Pandemic?
  • Surging Pandemic, Slumping Economy - And the Crisis of Democracy
  • Anxious Leader, Passive Citizens and "Criminalised" Governance
  • Parliamentary Session Merely A "Notice Board" For Government Decisions?
  • The Collapse of Democratic Institutions Under Majoritarian Rule
  • Mughal MUseum Rekindles Question of India's "Slavery""
  • Babri Masjid Demolition Case: Court Ignored Findings of Liberhan Commission
  • As Politics of Hate Takes Over, The Biggest Casualty is Compassion
  • Hathras: The Last Opportunity to Reflect
  • India Joining Ranks of Illiberal Democracies
  • Rising Uncertainties May Lead to Election Chaos in The us
  • 'Secularism': A Dirty Word
  • Is Bihar Tired of Nitish Kumar Rule?
  • In Crisis: India Now A 'Pale Shadow of Former Self'
  • Economy VS. People: Differences Between US and China's Response to Covid-19
  • Trupm is Gone But Trumpian Populism Lives on
  • Bihar's Silent Voters: Explaining the BJP-JDU Alliance
  • How Many X-Factors Can an Election Take? Many, it Seems
  • Objectivity and Fascism
  • Is The Saudi Kingdom Moving Towards Recognising Israel?
  • Asaduddin Owaisi: An 'Exasperating Opponent' For Right,Left, And Centre
  • 'Do Not Trifle With the Peasantry'
  • Is Modi's Popularity on the Decline?
  • Farmer's Agitation: A Spoke in The Wheel For BJP's Hindutva Strategy?
  • Maleeha Lodhi
  • A DYSFUNCTIONAL PARLIAMENT: POLITICAL COMPETITION LEADING TO THE DEMISE OF DISCUSSION AND DEBATE
  • Shaheen Bagh and the Farmers Protests, the Urban and the Rural
  • WILL US RUSSIA ESCALATE MILITARY TENSIONS?
  • A CASE OF ‘TOO MUCH’ OR TOO LITTLE DEMOCRACY?
  • MODI REGIME’S VISION FOR MEDIA INVOLVES TOTAL ALIGNMENT
  • FASCISM REARS ITS HEAD, A NEW THREAT FOR THE BIDEN PRESIDENCY
  • RIGHT TO PROTEST: PUBLIC MEETINGS A “TRADITION OF OUR NATIONAL LIFE”
  • Biden is Shifting Leftward?
  • The handmaiden of capitalism
  • ‘Lose a Battle to Win the War’- Kisan Leaders
  • People’s Power!
  • The Peasants Movement Constitutes a Major Crisis for Corporate Capital
  • Democracy Crumbles Under Central Push to Control NCT
  • Overzealous Crackdown in Jaffna Adds to Divide
  • Ambedkar and the Writing of History
  • ISRAEL'S METAMORPHOSIS FROM DAVID TO GOLIATH
  • UN PANEL PROPOSES ACTIONS TO PREVENT FUTURE PANDEMICS
  • ‘Outright Attack on the Land Rights of the People of Lakshadweep’
  • Biden Under Pressure to Harness Israel
  • THE POLITICAL JOURNEY OF MAMATA BANERJEE
  • A Public Health Necessity Gives Birth to Billionaires
  • THE END OF NETANYAHU AND ABBAS
  • This is No Time For Competition
  • WE ARE CREATING IDEAL CONDITIONS FOR FURTHER VIRUS EVOLUTION
  • THE IRAN HARDLINER WHO COULD HELP BIDEN
  • TALIBAN IN COMMAND AS US DOWNSIZES IN AFGHANISTAN
  •