The Big Private Crop Insurance Scam: Farmers Par Premium of Rs 482, Receive Rs 5 as Insurance!
of Tamil Nadu continue to be at the receiving end of an indifferent and callous
state. After paying huge premiums of Rs 212 for corn, and Rs 482 for cotton,
farmers received crop insurance cheques of Rs 5, Rs 7 and Rs 10 in many parts
of the state under the Prime
Ministers scheme Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana.
Karuppu Samy, Manivannan, Thangaraj and other farmers belonging to villages
Manjanaicken Patti, Poduvar Patti, Kalipatti in the Oddanchatram taluk of
Dindigul district in the state of Tamil Nadu received the cheques of Rs.5,
Rs.10 and Rs.20 for the failure of crops like corn and cotton being distributed
by the private insurance companies and state cooperative banks.
P.Ayyakannu, president, National South Indian River Interlinking Agriculturist
Association. told The Citizen, "the issue of cheques of Rs.5, Rs.10 as crop
insurance amount shows the farmers are being looked upon as slaves and second
class citizens in the country. The state and central governments give scant
respect for the issues of farmers in the era of corporatization and
privatization of agriculture".
S.Ranganathan, general secretary, Tamil Nadu Cauvery Delta Farmers Association,
told this writer, "Issuing of cheques for Rs.5, Rs.10 as crop insurance amount
is fooling the farmers". He added, "When the stage-wise crop insurance was
announced in the year 2016, we were happy, but now we find that we could not
understand the exact method of calculating the compensation. There is no
clarity among farmers, insurance officials and government officials about the
Jeeva Kumar, advocate and activist from Thanjavur told The Citizen, "Distribution of cheques of Rs.5, Rs10 and Rs20 isridiculing the dignity of
farmers. The state and central governments are boasting about the scheme. But,
the crop insurance scheme has failed in its objectives as the assessment and
implementation is an erroneous one. It needs drastic course correction".
Kakkarai Sukumaran, vice president of Joint Tamil Nadu Farmers Association was
categorical, "It is a humiliation and an insult to farmers and our profession".
He added, "The state and central governments have taken us for granted as we
are a fragmented group without any cohesiveness and unity. This has happened
because of the private insurance companies, they have collected premium from
the farmers running into crores, apart from delaying the disbursal of amount,
they are issuing the cheques for a meagre amount making a mockery of the
Alagi Annan from Chatira Patti, Oddanchatram Taluk of Dindigul district paid
the premium of Rs 112 for his Jowar(Sorghum) crop, but not yet received the
insurance amount for crop failure because of drought. He is now worried and as
he told this writer, now he is no longer sure whether he will be compensated
despite paying the premium.
There were numerous protests in the various parts of the state for the delayed
disbursal of the crop insurance amount by the concerned authorities. Now, the
meagre amount has further aggravated the situation. Opposition DMK took the
AIADMK government to task in the state Assembly recently. Finally the Ministers
of the ruling dispensation in Tamil Nadu claimed that these insulting amounts
were "clerical mistakes" and promised to rectify this soon.
The Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) was unveiled by Prime Minister
Narendra Modi on January 13 , 2016 after rolling back the earlier insurance
schemes viz. National Agriculture Insurance Scheme (NAIS), Weather-based Crop
Insurance scheme and Modified National Agricultural Insurance Scheme (MNAIS).
It aims at supporting sustainable production in agriculture sector by way of a)
providing financial support to farmers suffering crop loss/damage arising out
of unforeseen events b) stabilizing the income of farmers to ensure their
continuance in farming c) encouraging farmers to adopt innovative and modern
But the various studies and reports have pointed to the abject failure of the
scheme at the implementation level in various states of India, Tamil Nadu is no
Despite the flawed nature of this central scheme as observed by the policy
experts, the state government has not taken farmers into confidence inspite of
their prolonged protests at the national and state levels. More than 400
farmers committed suicide or died out of shock after the failed crops within a
year, but the AIADMK government shamelessly claimed in the Supreme Court that
no farmer has committed suicide in the state on account of the drought. The
insurance scam has come as a double whammy for the distressed agrarian
community in Tamil Nadu.